Retiring in New York: what taxes actually cost you
The short answer
On $80,000 of retirement income, New York costs about $10,635 a year across state income, property and sales tax. That ranks 43 of 51, or $4,000 above the median state. State income tax alone is $2,915, which is 3.6% of gross income.
Run it on your own numbers
The figures above use a reference profile. Change them and every number on this page moves, including the ranking.
How New York treats retirement income
New York runs a graduated income tax from 4% to 10.9%, with the top rate starting at $25,000,000 of taxable income for a single filer.
Social Security
Not taxed
Pension income
Taxed above $20,000
401(k) and IRA withdrawals
Taxed as ordinary income
Capital gains
Taxed as ordinary income
Property tax
Averages 1.72% of assessed value, so $6,880 a year on a $400K home.
Sales tax
State rate of 4%, before any local addition.
Worth knowing: NYC has additional tax. $20,000 pension exemption for 59.5+.
Where New York sits against the rest
The spread across all 51 runs from $3,280 in Wyoming to $14,004 in Connecticut, a difference of $10,724 a year on the same income.
Five cheapest on these numbers
| State | Total tax |
|---|---|
| Wyoming | $3,280 |
| Nevada | $3,639 |
| Colorado | $4,009 |
| Tennessee | $4,310 |
| Louisiana | $4,678 |
Five most expensive on these numbers
| State | Total tax |
|---|---|
| Connecticut | $14,004 |
| New Jersey | $12,953 |
| Vermont | $12,755 |
| Kansas | $11,108 |
| Minnesota | $10,888 |
Worth keeping in proportion. The gap between the best and worst state here is real money, but it is smaller than the gap between two housing markets, and it is far smaller than the effect of your withdrawal rate. Safe withdrawal rate covers that one.
Common questions
Does New York tax Social Security?
No. New York does not tax Social Security benefits at the state level. Federal tax on benefits still applies depending on your combined income.
How much tax would a retiree pay in New York?
On $80,000 of retirement income with a $400,000 home and $70,000 of annual spending, New York works out at roughly $10,635 a year across income, property and sales tax. That ranks 43 of 51, against a median of $6,635.
Does New York tax 401(k) and IRA withdrawals?
Yes. New York taxes withdrawals from 401(k)s and IRAs as ordinary income, with no retirement-specific exclusion.
Is New York a good state to retire in for taxes?
More expensive than most states. On the reference profile it costs $4,000 more than the median state, and $7,355 more than Wyoming, which is the cheapest. Tax is one input though. Cost of living, housing and proximity to family usually move a retirement budget further than the tax code does.
Retirement taxes in another state
Related: Taxes in retirement, Withdrawal order, Roth conversions, All 51 states.